
Problem Statement
The task is to identify all unique combinations of k different numbers that sum up to n, adhering to specific conditions: the numbers used must be from the set {1, 2, 3, ..., 9}, and each number can be used at most once in any combination. The goal is to produce a list containing all such valid combinations. These combinations should not repeat within the list, and the sequence in which these combinations appear does not matter.
Examples
Example 1
Input:
k = 3, n = 7
Output:
[[1,2,4]]
Explanation:
1 + 2 + 4 = 7 There are no other valid combinations.
Example 2
Input:
k = 3, n = 9
Output:
[[1,2,6],[1,3,5],[2,3,4]]
Explanation:
1 + 2 + 6 = 9 1 + 3 + 5 = 9 2 + 3 + 4 = 9 There are no other valid combinations.
Example 3
Input:
k = 4, n = 1
Output:
[]
Explanation:
There are no valid combinations. Using 4 different numbers in the range [1,9], the smallest sum we can get is 1+2+3+4 = 10 and since 10 > 1, there are no valid combination.
Constraints
2 <= k <= 91 <= n <= 60
Approach and Intuition
Considering the constraints and requirements provided, the solution can be effectively approached using a backtracking algorithm. Here’s why and how:
Optimal Elements Choice:
- We can only use the digits from 1 to 9.
- This small range allows us to exhaustively search for all combinations without a large computational cost.
Backtracking Strategy:
- Backtracking is suitable because it allows iterating over combinations of elements and "backtracking" as soon as a non-feasible path is identified.
- Here, non-feasible paths could be when the sum of chosen numbers exceeds
nor when more thanknumbers are picked.
Implementation Details:
- Begin with the smallest number (1) and move towards the highest (9).
- At each step:
- Include the current number into the running combination and proceed to the next number.
- If the combination is valid (sum equals
nand contains exactlyknumbers), record it. - If the sum exceeds
nor more thanknumbers are included, backtrack by removing the last added number and try the next available number. - Continue this process until all combinations starting from the current number are checked, and then move to the next starting number.
Efficiency Considerations:
- Remove numbers from consideration as soon as we know they will not lead to a valid solution (for example, if the current sum plus the smallest remaining number exceeds
n). - Since the output combinations must be unique, and we systematically generate combinations, we do not need to worry about explicitly checking for duplicate combinations.
- Remove numbers from consideration as soon as we know they will not lead to a valid solution (for example, if the current sum plus the smallest remaining number exceeds
Examples Interpretation:
- For input (k = 3, n = 7): The only combination that sums up to 7 using exactly three numbers from 1 to 9 is [1, 2, 4].
- For input (k = 3, n = 9): There are several possible combinations like [1, 2, 6], [1, 3, 5], and [2, 3, 4].
- For input (k = 4, n = 1): It's impossible to achieve a sum of 1 using four numbers from the given range; hence, the result is an empty array.
Conclusion
Understanding the constraints of the problem and the properties of numbers involved allows us to efficiently design a backtracking solution to explore all potential combinations. This method ensures we only compute what's necessary, minimizing redundant calculations and checks.
Solutions
- C++
- Java
- Python
class Solution {
public:
void explore(int left, int count, vector<int>& path, int start,
vector<vector<int>>& outputs) {
if (left == 0 && path.size() == count) {
outputs.push_back(path);
return;
} else if (left < 0 || path.size() == count) {
return;
}
for (int j = start; j < 9; ++j) {
path.push_back(j + 1);
this->explore(left - j - 1, count, path, j + 1, outputs);
path.pop_back();
}
}
vector<vector<int>> combinationSum3(int count, int target) {
vector<vector<int>> outputs;
vector<int> path;
this->explore(target, count, path, 0, outputs);
return outputs;
}
};
The "Combination Sum III" problem seeks combinations that add up to a specific target using a specific count of numbers between 1 and 9. Each combination must use only unique numbers. The implementation provided achieves this by using a depth-first search (DFS) approach:
The
combinationSum3function initializes the path and final outputs and starts the DFS exploration via theexplorefunction.The
explorefunction accepts parameters for the remaining sum (left), remaining number count (count), the current combination path (path), current number to consider (start), and the final list of valid combinations (outputs).In each recursive call:
- Check the base condition where if
leftequals 0 and the path length matches the count, add the path tooutputs. - If
leftgoes negative or the desired count is reached, the function returns without adding tooutputs. - Iterate from the
startnumber to 9, adding each number to the current path, then recursively callingexplorewith updatedleft, increased path elements, and next number.
- Check the base condition where if
Each number from 1 to 9 is tried once per recursion depth, ensuring unique sets and avoiding combinations of the same elements but in different orders.
This approach ensures efficient exploration of all possible combinations that meet the conditions imposed by the problem, and outputs all valid combinations by recursively building them and uniformly exploring potential candidate numbers.
class Solution {
protected void searchCombinations(
int remainingSum,
int combinationSize,
LinkedList<Integer> currentCombination,
int startNum,
List<List<Integer>> allCombinations
) {
if (remainingSum == 0 && currentCombination.size() == combinationSize) {
allCombinations.add(new ArrayList<Integer>(currentCombination));
return;
} else if (remainingSum < 0 || currentCombination.size() == combinationSize) {
return;
}
for (int num = startNum; num < 9; ++num) {
currentCombination.add(num + 1);
this.searchCombinations(remainingSum - num - 1, combinationSize, currentCombination, num + 1, allCombinations);
currentCombination.removeLast();
}
}
public List<List<Integer>> combinationSum3(int combinationSize, int targetSum) {
List<List<Integer>> allCombinations = new ArrayList<List<Integer>>();
LinkedList<Integer> comb = new LinkedList<Integer>();
this.searchCombinations(targetSum, combinationSize, comb, 0, allCombinations);
return allCombinations;
}
}
The Java solution provided outlines a method for finding all unique combinations of numbers that sum up to a given target sum, where each number can only be used once, and the combination must be exactly of a specified size. The solution uses recursion to explore possible combinations, leveraging backtracking to build up potential valid combinations and backtrack once an invalid path is confirmed.
Here's a summary of how the solution operates:
- The core functionality is encapsulated in the
searchCombinationsmethod, which recursively attempts to construct valid combinations that meet the criteria. - The method takes:
remainingSum: the sum left to reach the target.combinationSize: the size of each combination to be constructed.currentCombination: the current combination being constructed.startNum: the current number to start from in the recursive search.allCombinations: container to hold all the valid found combinations.
- Recursion is tailormade for this scenario:
- If
remainingSumequals zero andcurrentCombination's size equalscombinationSize, the current combination is added to theallCombinationslist, as it indicates a valid combination has been found. - If
remainingSumdrops below zero, orcurrentCombination's size exceedscombinationSize, it backtracks, avoiding invalid combinations.
- If
- It iteratively explores numbers from
startNumto 8 (num = startNum to < 9), representing choices from 1 through 9 (asnum + 1). For each number, it's added to thecurrentCombination, andsearchCombinationsis called with a decrementedremainingSum. - Post recursive call, it removes the last element added to revert to previous state (backtracking) and continues with the next number.
The combinationSum3 public method initializes parameters and kicks off the recursive search. It initializes:
allCombinations: to store valid combinations found.comb: a LinkedList used to store the current combination.
This method configures the initial state and calls searchCombinations, passing the initial configuration along with fresh parameters, starting from 0 to attempt to build lists up to the targetSum.
The solution leans heavily on recursion and backtracking to explore all potential number combinations, ensuring efficient exploration of possibilities while adhering to the constraint of unique combinations of a fixed size.
class Solution:
def findCombinationSums(self, count: int, target: int) -> List[List[int]]:
combinations = []
def searchCombinations(remainder, combination, start):
if remainder == 0 and len(combination) == count:
combinations.append(list(combination))
return
if remainder < 0 or len(combination) == count:
return
for num in range(start, 9):
combination.append(num + 1)
searchCombinations(remainder - num - 1, combination, num + 1)
combination.pop()
searchCombinations(target, [], 0)
return combinations
The given Python solution aims to solve the problem of finding all unique combinations that sum up to a target number (target), using exactly (count) numbers where each number can be used once from values 1 through 9. It defines a class, Solution, with a method findCombinationSums that initializes an empty list, combinations, to store the valid combinations.
Here's an outline of how the method works:
Start by defining an inner function
searchCombinations(remainder, combination, start)to perform recursive searches. The parameters are:remainder- the remaining sum needed to reach the target.combination- the current list of numbers contributing to the sum.start- the starting index for the next iteration to ensure numbers are not reused.
The base case checks if
remainderis zero and thecombinationlength equals the count. If true, it implies a valid combination that adds up to the target using the desired count of numbers, and adds a copy of this combination to thecombinationslist.If the
remainderis negative or the length ofcombinationexceedscount, the function returns as these conditions signify invalid combinations.A loop iterates from
startto 8 (inclusive), representing the digits 1 through 9 respectively. The function attempts to include the next number into the current combination, performs a recursive call adjusting theremainderandstartaccordingly, then backtracks by removing the last added number fromcombination.The main function call to
searchCombinationsinitiates the process with the full target, an empty list forcombinations, and 0 as the initial start value.Finally, the method returns the list of valid combinations.
Overall, the approach leverages backtracking to explore all possible number combinations, ensuring no repetitions and adherence to the constraints of using only numbers between 1 and 9.