
Problem Statement
Given an integer array named nums
and an integer k
, your goal is to determine the kth
largest element situated within the array. This should reflect the kth
largest in a manner akin to if the array were sorted, but it should not necessarily involve the direct sorting of the array itself, allowing for alternative algorithmic approaches. In this context, the specified kth
largest element relates to its position in a sorted sequence—not the kth
distinct value.
Examples
Example 1
Input:
nums = [3,2,1,5,6,4], k = 2
Output:
5
Example 2
Input:
nums = [3,2,3,1,2,4,5,5,6], k = 4
Output:
4
Constraints
1 <= k <= nums.length <= 105
-104 <= nums[i] <= 104
Approach and Intuition
The challenge here revolves around identifying the kth
largest value in an unsorted integer array. Diverse strategies exist for tackling this problem, some involving sorting while others leverage advanced data structures or algorithms for a more optimized solution. Here's a step-by-step breakdown of possible approaches:
Sorting-based Approach:
- A straightforward method involves sorting the array in descending order and then simply picking the
kth
element from the sorted array. This approach, while direct and easy to understand, may not be the most efficient, particularly for large arrays, given itsO(n log n)
complexity.
- A straightforward method involves sorting the array in descending order and then simply picking the
Heap-based Approach:
- Utilizing a min-heap (or priority queue) of size
k
offers a more optimal solution. By iterating through the array and maintaining a heap size ofk
, you ensure that the heap always holds thek
largest elements encountered so far. Once you've processed all elements:- The top of the min-heap will represent the
kth
largest element. - This approach has a better average time complexity, especially for large values of
k
, at aroundO(n log k)
.
- The top of the min-heap will represent the
- Utilizing a min-heap (or priority queue) of size
Quickselect Algorithm:
- Quickselect is a selection algorithm to find the
kth
smallest (or largest with slight modifications) element in an unordered list. It is related to the quicksort sorting algorithm. Using Quickselect, you can achieve an average time complexity ofO(n)
though in the worst case it can degrade toO(n^2)
. - The algorithm operates by partitioning the array into two parts, those less than a chosen pivot and those greater than it. By recursively applying this strategy to the appropriate part of the array, you converge upon the
kth
largest element.
- Quickselect is a selection algorithm to find the
Randomized Quickselect:
- This is a variation of the Quickselect that uses randomization to improve the average-case performance time and reduce the likelihood of worst-case scenarios, thus providing robust performance across different inputs.
Divide and Conquer:
- Similar to Quickselect, other divide and conquer methods can be used to break down the problem into smaller subproblems, solve each independently, and combine the results.
Median of Medians Algorithm:
- This is an advanced algorithm that finds the median in a more deterministic worst-case time, which can also be adapted to find the
kth
largest element. It's an intricate method often used in theoretical computer science to guarantee linear time complexity.
- This is an advanced algorithm that finds the median in a more deterministic worst-case time, which can also be adapted to find the
Each approach has its trade-offs regarding complexity and efficiency, and the choice of method can depend on the size of the data, the position of k
, and performance considerations.
Solutions
- C++
- Java
- Python
class Solution {
public:
int findKthLargestElement(vector<int>& elements, int k) {
int smallest = INT_MAX;
int largest = INT_MIN;
for (int value: elements) {
smallest = min(smallest, value);
largest = max(largest, value);
}
vector<int> freq(largest - smallest + 1);
for (int value: elements) {
freq[value - smallest]++;
}
int counter = k;
for (int i = freq.size() - 1; i >= 0; i--) {
counter -= freq[i];
if (counter <= 0) {
return i + smallest;
}
}
return -1;
}
};
This solution demonstrates how to find the Kth largest element in an array using C++. The approach involves the following steps:
- Initialize two variables,
smallest
andlargest
, to track the minimum and maximum elements in the array respectively. - Iterate through the array to determine the
smallest
andlargest
values. - Create a frequency array
freq
sized to the range betweensmallest
andlargest
. This array will store the count of each element in the initial array, adjusted by subtractingsmallest
to index appropriately. - Populate the
freq
array with the frequency of each element inelements
. - Initialize a counter
counter
with the value ofk
. - Traverse the
freq
array backward, decrementingcounter
by the frequency of each element. Ifcounter
reaches zero or goes negative, the Kth largest element is found at the current index adjusted bysmallest
. - If no element is found after the complete traversal, return -1.
This method effectively finds the Kth largest element without explicitly sorting the array, leveraging counting and array indexing to achieve the result. Make sure to understand the flow of index adjustments and the role of the frequency array in deducing the Kth largest element from the back of the adjusted array.
class Solution {
public int kthLargestElement(int[] array, int k) {
int minElement = Integer.MAX_VALUE;
int maxElement = Integer.MIN_VALUE;
for (int value: array) {
minElement = Math.min(minElement, value);
maxElement = Math.max(maxElement, value);
}
int[] frequency = new int[maxElement - minElement + 1];
for (int value: array) {
frequency[value - minElement]++;
}
int target = k;
for (int i = frequency.length - 1; i >= 0; i--) {
target -= frequency[i];
if (target <= 0) {
return i + minElement;
}
}
return -1;
}
}
The provided Java method kthLargestElement
efficiently finds the k-th largest element in a given array using a counting sort mechanism tailored for this specific task. Below is a summary of how the solution works:
- Initially, determine the smallest (
minElement
) and largest (maxElement
) values in the array. These values help in sizing the frequency array correctly. - Create
frequency
, an array that tracks the number of occurrences of each value within the adjusted range based onminElement
andmaxElement
. Specifically, the index in thefrequency
array for any elementvalue
from the input array is calculated asvalue - minElement
. - Iterate through the
frequency
array from highest index (largest element) to lowest (smallest element), subtracting the count of each element fromk
untilk
becomes less than or equal to zero. At this point, the current index points to the value that is the k-th largest element. - The adjusted index value is calculated by adding
minElement
to align it with actual data values.
This approach gracefully manages to avoid the pitfalls of direct sorting which could be less efficient for larger arrays, opting instead for a counting mechanism which is generally more time-efficient, operating within linear complexity under suitable conditions (bounded range of integer elements).
class Solution:
def kthLargestFinder(self, numbers: List[int], position: int) -> int:
smallest = min(numbers)
largest = max(numbers)
frequency = [0] * (largest - smallest + 1)
for number in numbers:
frequency[number - smallest] += 1
remaining = position
for idx in range(len(frequency) - 1, -1, -1):
remaining -= frequency[idx]
if remaining <= 0:
return idx + smallest
return -1
This solution describes a Python program for finding the kth largest element in an array using a specialized counting sort approach. The function kthLargestFinder
accepts two arguments: a list numbers
and an integer position
indicating the kth position.
Start by calculating the minimum (
smallest
) and maximum (largest
) values in the array. This establishes the range for the frequency array.Initialize a frequency array of size
(largest - smallest + 1)
to zero. This array will count occurrences of each element innumbers
, adjusted by thesmallest
value.Iterate over
numbers
, populating the frequency array. For each number, increment the value in the frequency array at the index corresponding to(number - smallest)
.Set
remaining
to the value ofposition
. This variable tracks how many more elements need to be counted down from the highest elements to reach the kth largest.Iterate backward through the frequency array. For each index, decrement
remaining
by the frequency count at that index. Ifremaining
becomes zero or negative, return the element corresponding to this index, adjusted by addingsmallest
.If the loop completes without finding the kth largest element, return
-1
as a failure condition.
This approach efficiently handles arrays with a limited range of integer values, using the counting sort technique for direct access to frequency counts and adjusting for position reversals to find the kth largest value.
No comments yet.