
Problem Statement
In the given problem, we have multiple spherical balloons stuck to a flat wall, represented on the XY-plane. Each balloon is described by its horizontal spread on this plane through a pair of integers [xstart, xend]
, which indicates the stretch of the balloon from xstart
to xend
on the X-axis. However, the vertical position or height (Y-coordinates) of these balloons is unknown.
We need to burst all these balloons using arrows that are shot vertically upwards from any position along the X-axis. A balloon is considered burst by an arrow if the horizontal position of the arrow's launch (x
) lies within the balloon’s horizontal range (xstart <= x <= xend
). Importantly, there's no restriction on the number of arrows that can be shot, but each arrow will continue to travel upwards indefinitely once shot.
Our task is to determine the minimum number of arrows required to burst all the balloons.
Examples
Example 1
Input:
points = [[10,16],[2,8],[1,6],[7,12]]
Output:
2
Explanation:
The balloons can be burst by 2 arrows: - Shoot an arrow at x = 6, bursting the balloons [2,8] and [1,6]. - Shoot an arrow at x = 11, bursting the balloons [10,16] and [7,12].
Example 2
Input:
points = [[1,2],[3,4],[5,6],[7,8]]
Output:
4
Explanation:
One arrow needs to be shot for each balloon for a total of 4 arrows.
Example 3
Input:
points = [[1,2],[2,3],[3,4],[4,5]]
Output:
2
Explanation:
The balloons can be burst by 2 arrows: - Shoot an arrow at x = 2, bursting the balloons [1,2] and [2,3]. - Shoot an arrow at x = 4, bursting the balloons [3,4] and [4,5].
Constraints
1 <= points.length <= 105
points[i].length == 2
-231 <= xstart < xend <= 231 - 1
Approach and Intuition
The goal is to minimize the number of arrows, which implies an optimal placement of these arrows such that one arrow can burst more than one balloon if possible. The problem essentially turns into a variant of the interval scheduling maximization problem, where instead of selecting the maximum number of non-overlapping intervals, we aim to minimize the points (arrows) to cover all given intervals (balloons).
Here’s how we can think about solving this problem:
Sort the Balloons by End Coordinates: First, sort the
points
based on theirxend
values. Sorting by the end coordinates of each interval helps us determine the critical points where placing an arrow would burst the maximum number of balloons finishing at or before that point.Placing the Arrow at the End of Overlapping Balloons: Start with placing an arrow at the end of the first balloon in the sorted order. This arrow will burst all balloons that start before this arrow point or exactly at it.
Continue for Non-Burst Balloons: Move to the next balloon which hasn't burst yet (i.e., the first balloon whose starting point is beyond the current arrow's position). Place the next arrow at this balloon's end point.
Repeat Until All are Burst: Continue this process until all balloons are accounted for.
Based on the examples, this method effectively reduces the number of arrows:
- In Example 1, sorting by end points and then placing arrows at the ends of feasible intervals reduced the arrows to 2, bursting all balloons as described.
- In Example 2, no two balloons overlapped, hence each needed a separate arrow.
- In Example 3, arrows were placed at overlap points, reducing the total arrows needed to 2.
With these steps, we ensure a solution with the minimum number of arrows required to burst all balloons.
Solutions
- C++
- Java
- Python
class Solution {
public:
int minArrowsToBurstBalloons(vector<vector<int>>& balloons) {
if (balloons.empty()) return 0;
// sorting on the end position of balloons
sort(balloons.begin(), balloons.end(), [](const vector<int> &a, const vector<int> &b) {
return a[1] < b[1];
});
int arrowCount = 1;
int start, end, lastEnd = balloons[0][1];
for (const auto &balloon : balloons) {
start = balloon[0];
end = balloon[1];
// New arrow is needed when a balloon starts after the last one ends
if (lastEnd < start) {
arrowCount++;
lastEnd = end;
}
}
return arrowCount;
}
};
This solution implements an algorithm to find the minimum number of arrows required to burst all the given balloons using C++ programming language. The code operates by first determining if the balloon list is empty. If it is, you return 0, meaning no arrows are needed.
The key operational steps are as follows:
Sort the
balloons
vector based on the end coordinates of the balloons. This allows for an efficient approach to determine the minimum number of arrows by focusing on where balloons end.Initialize
arrowCount
to 1 since at least one arrow will be needed if there are any balloons.Loop through the sorted balloon intervals and detect the requirement for new arrows. For each balloon, it checks whether the starting point of the current balloon is beyond the end point of the last encountered balloon.
- If true, increment the
arrowCount
, indicating a need for a new arrow, and updatelastEnd
to the current balloon's end.
- If true, increment the
The function returns the count of arrows required.
This algorithm leverages sorting and a simple iteration, ensuring that the time complexity is dominated by the sorting process, hence the overall time complexity is O(n log n), where n
is the number of balloons.
class Solver {
public int countArrows(int[][] coordinates) {
if (coordinates.length == 0) return 0;
// Sort by balloon endpoint
Arrays.sort(coordinates, (first, second) -> Integer.compare(first[1], second[1]));
int requiredArrows = 1;
int start, end, lastEnd = coordinates[0][1];
for (int[] balloon: coordinates) {
start = balloon[0];
end = balloon[1];
// Check if a new arrow is needed
if (lastEnd < start) {
requiredArrows++;
lastEnd = end;
}
}
return requiredArrows;
}
}
The provided Java program aims to solve the problem of determining the minimum number of arrows required to burst all balloons represented by intervals. Each balloon is given as a range where it can be burst.
The approach taken includes the following steps:
- Check if the input array of balloon coordinates is empty. If it is, return 0 since no arrows are needed.
- Sort the balloon coordinates by their end points. This facilitates the process of finding overlapping intervals which can be burst by a single arrow.
- Initialize the required number of arrows to one. Assume at least one arrow is needed for the first balloon.
- Track the end point of the last burst balloon in
lastEnd
. - Traverse each balloon, comparing the start point of the current balloon with
lastEnd
. - If the start point is greater than
lastEnd
, this indicates that the current balloon doesn't overlap with the previous one, hence an additional arrow is necessary. - Update
lastEnd
to the end point of the current balloon if a new arrow is used.
By efficiently checking for overlapping intervals and counting the necessary instances where a new arrow must be used, the program successfully calculates the minimum number of arrows required. The use of sorting by end coordinates simplifies the logic needed to determine overlapping balloons. This solution is both effective in terms of time complexity, due to sorting taking O(n log n) time, and in terms of space complexity, as it operates in O(1) space, not counting the input.
class Solution:
def minArrowsNeeded(self, intervals: List[List[int]]) -> int:
if not intervals:
return 0
# Sort by ending coordinate
intervals.sort(key=lambda point: point[1])
num_arrows = 1
end_of_last_burst = intervals[0][1]
for start, end in intervals:
# Check for non-overlapping balloons
if end_of_last_burst < start:
num_arrows += 1
end_of_last_burst = end
return num_arrows
This solution deals with finding the minimum number of arrows required to burst all balloons characterized by intervals where each interval represents a balloon's horizontal relative position of start and end points. The solution, implemented in Python 3, follows these steps:
Check if there are no balloons. If true, return 0 as no arrows are needed.
Sort the list of intervals by each balloon's ending point. This step is crucial as it simplifies the process of finding overlapping balloons.
Initialize a counter for arrows required (
num_arrows
) starting with one arrow, assuming at least one balloon exists.Keep track of the ending point of the last burst balloon (
end_of_last_burst
). This is initially set to the end point of the first balloon in the sorted list.Iterate over each balloon's interval. If the starting point of the current balloon is greater than
end_of_last_burst
, it indicates that this balloon doesn't overlap with the previously considered ones, hence an additional arrow is needed. Updateend_of_last_burst
to the current balloon's end point.Finally, return the total number of arrows needed (
num_arrows
).
This approach ensures that the minimum number of arrows is used by making use of sorting based on end positions of balloons, which allows for an efficient check of overlaps. The provided Python 3 code effectively applies logical decisions to ascertain when additional arrows are needed and successfully calculates the result based on interval management.
No comments yet.