Remove Stones to Minimize the Total

Updated on 20 June, 2025
Remove Stones to Minimize the Total header image

Problem Statement

In this problem, we are provided with an array piles indexed from zero, where each element piles[i] denotes the count of stones in the i-th pile. Additionally, we're given an integer k representing the number of operations to be performed. The specific operation entails selecting any pile piles[i], then removing the integer part of half the stones from it, which is mathematically described as floor(piles[i] / 2). Note that an operation can be reiterated on the same pile more than once if needed.

Our goal is to find the least number of stones that can be achieved after executing the operation k times across any of the piles.

The function floor(x) returns the largest integer less than or equal to x, effectively rounding down decimal values. This means during each operation up to half of the stones (rounded down) can potentially be removed from the chosen pile.

Examples

Example 1

Input:

piles = [5,4,9], k = 2

Output:

12

Explanation:

 Steps of a possible scenario are:
- Apply the operation on pile 2. The resulting piles are [5,4,5].
- Apply the operation on pile 0. The resulting piles are [3,4,5].
The total number of stones in [3,4,5] is 12.

Example 2

Input:

piles = [4,3,6,7], k = 3

Output:

12

Explanation:

 Steps of a possible scenario are:
- Apply the operation on pile 2. The resulting piles are [4,3,3,7].
- Apply the operation on pile 3. The resulting piles are [4,3,3,4].
- Apply the operation on pile 0. The resulting piles are [2,3,3,4].
The total number of stones in [2,3,3,4] is 12.

Constraints

  • 1 <= piles.length <= 105
  • 1 <= piles[i] <= 104
  • 1 <= k <= 105

Approach and Intuition

The challenge involves strategically removing stones to achieve the minimum possible total. Here's an intuitive approach to tackle this:

  1. Maximize Stone Removal Per Operation:

    • Always target the pile with the most stones for the greatest reduction.
    • After each operation, the pile’s priority could change as it may not remain the highest anymore.
  2. Utilize a Max-Heap or Priority Queue:

    • Store each pile's stones in a max-heap which always gives us the pile with the maximum stones first.
    • This structure will allow efficient retrieval and updates of top elements.
  3. Steps:

    1. Start by pushing all stones counts from piles into the max-heap.
    2. For each of the k operations:
      1. Extract the top element (the highest stone count).
      2. Compute the stones to remove: floor(current top aspect/2).
      3. Subtract these stones from the current top aspect and reinsert it into the heap.
      4. This ensures that in the next operation, again the pile with the currently highest stones is considered first.
    3. After all operations, aggregate the stones by summing items left in the heap.

The approach leverages the nature of max-heaps for efficient max element lookup and inserts, ensuring that operations are always applied to piles where they yield maximum reductions. Thus, adhering to this strategy should ideally bring us closer to the minimum remaining stones after k operations.

Solutions

  • C++
  • Java
  • Python
cpp
class Solution {
public:
    int reduceStones(vector<int>& stones, int operations) {
        priority_queue<int> maxHeap(stones.begin(), stones.end());
        int currentSum = accumulate(stones.begin(), stones.end(), 0);
        
        for (int op = 0; op < operations; op++) {
            int topStone = maxHeap.top();
            maxHeap.pop();
            int reducedValue = topStone / 2;
            currentSum -= reducedValue;
            maxHeap.push(topStone - reducedValue);
        }
        
        return currentSum;
    }
};

In the C++ solution for minimizing the total number of stones through a series of operations, the approach utilizes a max-heap and operations to decrease the largest stone by half each time to reduce the overall sum of stones effectively.

  • Create a max-heap from the given list of stones to always access the largest stone quickly.
  • Calculate the initial sum of all stones.
  • For a given number of operations, repeatedly remove the largest stone from the heap, reduce its value by half, and then place the reduced stone back into the heap.
  • Adjust the total sum of stones by subtracting the amount reduced in each operation.
  • Finally, return the new sum of stones after all operations have been performed.

This method ensures efficient manipulation and retrieval of stone quantities, crucial to minimizing the total number of stones as much as possible within the allowed operations.

java
class Solution {
    public int reducePiles(int[] stones, int maxRemoves) {
        PriorityQueue<Integer> maxHeap = new PriorityQueue<>((x, y) -> y - x);
        for (int stone: stones) {
            maxHeap.add(stone);
        }
        
        for (int i = 0; i < maxRemoves; i++) {
            int top = maxHeap.poll();
            maxHeap.add(top - (top / 2));
        }
        
        int total = 0;
        for (int stone: maxHeap) {
            total += stone;
        }
        
        return total;
    }
}

This Java program provides a solution to the problem of reducing the total number of stones by executing a specified number of removal operations. The goal is to minimize the total sum of stones left after a certain number of the largest piles are reduced by half a maximum number of times, defined by maxRemoves.

  • Begin by initializing a PriorityQueue, maxHeap, which will sort elements in descending order. This helps efficiently access and remove the largest pile of stones.
  • Populate the maxHeap with the array stones. Each element represents the count of stones in a pile.
  • Iterate up to maxRemoves times, performing the following operations:
    1. Remove the largest pile from maxHeap.
    2. Calculate half of this pile and subtract it from the original pile size.
    3. Add the resultant value back to the maxHeap.
  • After the operations, iterate over the elements of maxHeap and sum them up to compute the total amount of stones left.
  • Return the total amount of stones.

This solution effectively uses the properties of the heap data structure, specifically a max-heap, to continuously identify and reduce the largest pile efficiently, thus minimizing the total number of stones in the given number of operations.

python
import heapq

class Solution:
    def reduceStones(self, stones: List[int], operations: int) -> int:
        max_heap = [-stone for stone in stones]
        heapq.heapify(max_heap)

        for _ in range(operations):
            largest_stone = -heapq.heappop(max_heap)
            reduced = largest_stone // 2
            heapq.heappush(max_heap, -(largest_stone - reduced))

        return -sum(max_heap)

The "Remove Stones to Minimize the Total" Python3 solution operates by transforming a list of stone weights into a max heap to efficiently perform operations aimed at minimizing the total weight. The implementation encompasses the use of Python's heapq module, which facilitates heap operations on a list interpreted as a heap.

  • Initialize a list max_heap, converting each stone weight to a negative value to simulate a max heap using Python's min heap structure.
  • Use heapq.heapify(max_heap) to transform the list into a heap.
  • For each operation (up to the number specified):
    • Remove the largest element from the heap (-heapq.heappop(max_heap)), which simulates popping the maximum value.
    • Calculate the reduced weight by dividing the popped stone's weight by 2.
    • Insert the new weight back into the heap to preserve heap properties.
  • Return the negated sum of all elements in the heap to provide the minimized total stone weight.

This approach ensures that the largest stones are reduced first, effectively decreasing the total weight as much as possible per operation. The use of a heap data structure optimizes the process of finding and removing the largest stone, ensuring that the solution efficiently handles operations within the constraint limits.

Comments

No comments yet.