
Problem Statement
In the problem, sentences are represented as arrays of words and we are provided two such arrays, sentence1
and sentence2
. Along with these sentences, an array of pairs, similarPairs
, is given which denotes word similarities between the elements of these arrays.
The task is to determine if sentence1
and sentence2
are similar based on two criteria:
- Both sentences must have the exact same number of words.
- Corresponding words in each sentence are considered similar either if they are exactly the same or if they are deemed similar according to the
similarPairs
list.
It's crucial to note that similarity is not transitive in this context. That means even if word A is similar to word B, and word B is similar to word C, word A does not necessarily have to be similar to word C.
Examples
Example 1
Input:
sentence1 = ["great","acting","skills"], sentence2 = ["fine","drama","talent"], similarPairs = [["great","fine"],["drama","acting"],["skills","talent"]]
Output:
true
Explanation:
The two sentences have the same length and each word i of sentence1 is also similar to the corresponding word in sentence2.
Example 2
Input:
sentence1 = ["great"], sentence2 = ["great"], similarPairs = []
Output:
true
Explanation:
A word is similar to itself.
Example 3
Input:
sentence1 = ["great"], sentence2 = ["doubleplus","good"], similarPairs = [["great","doubleplus"]]
Output:
false
Explanation:
As they don't have the same length, we return false.
Constraints
1 <= sentence1.length, sentence2.length <= 1000
1 <= sentence1[i].length, sentence2[i].length <= 20
sentence1[i]
andsentence2[i]
consist of English letters.0 <= similarPairs.length <= 1000
similarPairs[i].length == 2
1 <= xi.length, yi.length <= 20
xi
andyi
consist of lower-case and upper-case English letters.- All the pairs
(xi, yi)
are distinct.
Approach and Intuition
Understanding the problem requires us to handle string array comparisons and use a mapping strategy for the similarity pairs for efficient lookup. Here’s a step-by-step breakdown of how we can approach this:
Check Sentence Length: First, ensure that both
sentence1
andsentence2
have the same number of words. If not, we immediately returnfalse
.Mapping Similarities: Convert the list of
similarPairs
to a dictionary (or hashmap) for O(1) average time complexity on lookups. Each entry in the dictionary takes the form of{word: set(similar_words)}
, thereby grouping each word with its corresponding set of similar words.Comparing Words: Iterate over each word in both sentences simultaneously:
- If the current words in both sentences are identical, they are naturally similar.
- If they are different, look up each word in the similarity dictionary:
- Check if the word from
sentence1
exists in the set of similar words for the corresponding word fromsentence2
and vice versa.
- Check if the word from
- If any word pair doesn't satisfy the similarity condition, we return
false
.
Return Result: If all word pairs from both sentences are found similar by the above conditions, the function should return
true
, concluding that both sentences are similar. If any condition fails at any point, the function should returnfalse
.
By structuring the approach with efficient data structures and ensuring early exits on mismatch, the solution is both time and space optimized within the given constraints. This method utilizes computational resources in an effective manner while adhering to the problem's requirements.
Solutions
- C++
class Solution {
public:
bool sentencesCompare(vector<string>& sent1, vector<string>& sent2,
vector<vector<string>>& similar) {
if (sent1.size() != sent2.size()) {
return false;
}
unordered_map<string, unordered_set<string>> similarMap;
for (auto& pair : similar) {
similarMap[pair[0]].insert(pair[1]);
similarMap[pair[1]].insert(pair[0]);
}
for (int idx = 0; idx < sent1.size(); idx++) {
// Check if the words are the same
if (sent1[idx] == sent2[idx]) {
continue;
}
// Check if there exists a similarity in words
if (similarMap[sent1[idx]].find(sent2[idx]) != similarMap[sent1[idx]].end()) {
continue;
}
return false;
}
return true;
}
};
This C++ solution checks if two sentences represented by the vectors sent1
and sent2
are similar based on a given list of pairs of similar words. The core concept is to leverage a hash map to store each word of the similar pairs for quick look-up, ensuring an efficient comparison process. Here's the breakdown of how the solution accomplishes this:
- Begin by comparing the sizes of
sent1
andsent2
. If they differ, the sentences are immediately deemed dissimilar, and the function returnsfalse
. - Create an
unordered_map
namedsimilarMap
where each key is a word from the list of similar pairs, and its value is anunordered_set
containing the words it is similar to. This setup allows the checking of word similarity in constant time. - Populate
similarMap
by iterating over the listsimilar
. For each pair of similar words, add each word as a key pointing to the other as part of its set. This ensures mutual mapping, i.e., if "A" is similar to "B", then "B" is also similar to "A". - Iterate through the sentences using an index. For each position, check if the words in
sent1
andsent2
are either the same or present as similar insimilarMap
. - If two corresponding words are neither identical nor listed as similar, return
false
, indicating that the sentences are not similar. - If all checks throughout the iteration pass, return
true
, confirming the similarity ofsent1
andsent2
.
This approach effectively scales with input size due to the constant-time efficiency of hash map and set operations, thus providing a robust solution to sentence similarity checking.
- Java
class Solution {
public
boolean areWordsSimilar(String[] words1, String[] words2, List<List<String>> pairs) {
if (words1.length != words2.length) {
return false;
}
Map<String, Set<String>> mapPairs = new HashMap<>();
for (List<String> pair : pairs) {
mapPairs.computeIfAbsent(pair.get(0), k -> new HashSet<>()).add(pair.get(1));
mapPairs.computeIfAbsent(pair.get(1), k -> new HashSet<>()).add(pair.get(0));
}
for (int index = 0; index < words1.length; index++) {
if (words1[index].equals(words2[index])) {
continue;
}
if (mapPairs.containsKey(words1[index]) && mapPairs.get(words1[index]).contains(words2[index])) {
continue;
}
return false;
}
return true;
}
}
The provided Java solution is designed to determine if two arrays of words, words1
and words2
, are similar based on a list of given pairs that define which words are considered similar. Follow this step-by-step explanation of the code to understand its logic and operation:
The method
areWordsSimilar
checks if the lengths ofwords1
andwords2
are the same. If they differ, it immediately returns false, ensuring that further comparison only occurs between arrays of equal length.It defines a
HashMap
namedmapPairs
which will store each word and its corresponding set of similar words. This facilitates quick lookup to check word similarity.The method then populates this map using the
pairs
list. For each pair, it ensures both words reference each other as similar by accessing or creating a newHashSet
for each word and adding the counterpart word.After setting up the mapping of similar words, the function iterates through both word arrays simultaneously by index. For each pair of words:
- If the words at the current index in
words1
andwords2
are identical, it skips to the next pair. - If the words are different, it checks
mapPairs
to see if the first word considers the second word similar (i.e., if the second word is contained in the set of similar words of the first). If not, the method returns false.
- If the words at the current index in
If all checks pass, the method concludes that the two arrays of words are similar based on the provided pairs and returns true.
This approach prioritizes efficiency in checking word similarity by using a combination of hash maps and sets. By setting up a bidirectional similarity map at the beginning, it ensures quick lookups and minimal iteration thereafter.
- Python
class Solution(object):
def checkSimilarity(self, s1, s2, pairs):
if len(s1) != len(s2):
return False
synonyms = defaultdict(set)
for first, second in pairs:
synonyms[first].add(second)
synonyms[second].add(first)
for idx in range(len(s1)):
if s1[idx] == s2[idx] or s2[idx] in synonyms[s1[idx]]:
continue
return False
return True
This Python solution is designed to check the similarity between two sentences based on given pairs of synonyms. The function checkSimilarity
takes three parameters: s1
and s2
for the sentences and pairs
containing possible synonym relationships. Follow these guidelines to understand the implementation:
Initially, it checks if both sentences
s1
ands2
are of the same length. If not, it immediately returnsFalse
, as differing lengths preclude similarity.It sets up a
defaultdict
of sets namedsynonyms
to store all provided synonym pairs in a two-way relationship, meaning ifa
is a synonym ofb
, thenb
is considered a synonym ofa
.The function then iterates through each word in the sentences by their index. For each pair of corresponding words from
s1
ands2
, it checks:- If the words are exactly the same.
- If the word from
s2
exists in the set of synonyms for the corresponding word froms1
.
If neither condition is true, the function returns
False
.If all pairs of words pass the similarity check, it returns
True
, confirming that the sentences are similar based on the given synonym pairs.
This approach efficiently utilizes set operations for quick look-up and ensures only relevant synonym checks are made by using a dictionary of sets.
No comments yet.