
Problem Statement
The variance of a string is the largest numerical difference between the counts of any two characters within that string. In this problem, you are required to calculate this maximum variance but not just for the whole string 's', but for all possible substrings of 's'. A substring is defined as a sequence of consecutive characters taken from 's'. The challenge lies in determining the largest variance possible among these substrings, all of which are made up exclusively of lowercase English letters.
Examples
Example 1
Input:
s = "aababbb"
Output:
3
Explanation:
All possible variances along with their respective substrings are listed below: - Variance 0 for substrings "a", "aa", "ab", "abab", "aababb", "ba", "b", "bb", and "bbb". - Variance 1 for substrings "aab", "aba", "abb", "aabab", "ababb", "aababbb", and "bab". - Variance 2 for substrings "aaba", "ababbb", "abbb", and "babb". - Variance 3 for substring "babbb". Since the largest possible variance is 3, we return it.
Example 2
Input:
s = "abcde"
Output:
0
Explanation:
No letter occurs more than once in s, so the variance of every substring is 0.
Constraints
1 <= s.length <= 104
s
consists of lowercase English letters.
Approach and Intuition
The solution to this problem involves both understanding substrings and character count discrepancies within these substrings.
Identifying Unique Characters: Since the string consists only of lowercase letters, the difference in characters' occurrence will drive the variance.
Evaluate Each Substring: Typically, the substring with the highest frequency of one character and the lowest (or zero) frequency of another character will give the maximum variance. For example, a substring heavily skewed towards one particular character will inherently have high variance if there's another character present few or no times.
Edge Conditions: If a string or any of its substrings consists of one unique character, the variance will be 0 because there are no other characters to produce a count difference.
Analyzing Examples:
- For the string "aababbb":
- Consider the substring “babbb”—'b' appears four times, 'a' appears once, so the variance is 4-1=3, which is the maximum for this string.
- For the string "abcde":
- Each character appears exactly once in different substrings like “ab”, “bc”, etc., and thus, there is no variance as all counts are equal.
- For the string "aababbb":
Optimizing the Search: Given that evaluating all substrings could be computationally expensive, especially for larger strings (up to 10,000 characters long as per the constraints), an optimized approach rather than a brute-force one is necessary. This might involve using advanced techniques like dynamic programming or optimized sliding windows to track character counts and update variances efficiently.
Considering Constraints:
- The single character string edge case ensures that the function handles the smallest inputs (1 character) gracefully.
- Handling up to 10,000 characters requires ensuring that the solution is efficient and scales well without excessive time or space complexity.
By breaking down the problem in this structured manner and considering various edge cases and optimizations, the task becomes more manageable and clear pathways to the solution emerge.
Solutions
- C++
class Solution {
public:
int findMaxVariance(string str) {
vector<int> freq(26, 0);
for (char c : str) {
freq[c - 'a']++;
}
int maxVariance = 0;
for (int primary = 0; primary < 26; primary++) {
for (int secondary = 0; secondary < 26; secondary++) {
// primary and secondary must be distinct and present in the string
if (primary == secondary || freq[primary] == 0 || freq[secondary] == 0) {
continue;
}
char highFreqChar = 'a' + primary;
char lowFreqChar = 'a' + secondary;
int highCount = 0;
int lowCount = 0;
// Remaining instances of low frequency character
int remainingLow = freq[secondary];
for (char element : str) {
if (element == highFreqChar) {
highCount++;
}
if (element == lowFreqChar) {
lowCount++;
remainingLow--;
}
// Update maxVariance if any lowFreqChar seen so far
if (lowCount > 0)
maxVariance = max(maxVariance, highCount - lowCount);
// Reset counts when high is less than low and there are remaining lows
if (highCount < lowCount && remainingLow > 0) {
highCount = 0;
lowCount = 0;
}
}
}
}
return maxVariance;
}
};
This solution aims to solve the "Substring With Largest Variance" problem, which involves finding the maximum variance between the frequency counts of two distinct characters in any substring of a given string. The code is implemented in C++ and can be summarized by the following:
Frequency Calculation: Initially, compute the frequency of each character in the string using an array
freq
, which counts occurrences of each character from 'a' to 'z'.Nested Iteration Over Characters: Use two nested loops to iterate over possible pairs of characters (denoted by indices
primary
andsecondary
representing characters from 'a' to 'z'). These characters represent potential high and low frequency characters in substrings.Condition Checks: For each pair, check whether they are distinct and both are present in the string. Skip the iteration if they are the same or if either character is not present in the string.
Variance Calculation For Each Pair: Initialize counters for high frequency character (
highCount
) and low frequency character (lowCount
), then iterate through the string, updating these counts whenever their corresponding characters are encountered.Reset on Low Instances Remaining: If the currently considered substring has ended (determined by
highCount
being less thanlowCount
and the presence of remaining low frequency characters), reset both counts to zero to start counting for a new potential substring.Updating Maximum Variance: If
lowCount
is positive, indicating that the low frequency character has been encountered, updatemaxVariance
if the differencehighCount - lowCount
is greater than the currentmaxVariance
.
Return Result: After evaluating all possible pairs and substrings, return
maxVariance
, which contains the largest variance found.
This method efficiently identifies the substring that exhibits the highest variance between the counts of any two distinct characters, leveraging a combination of frequency counting and iteratively assessing potential substrings through character-specific counters.
- Java
class Solution {
public int maxVariance(String str) {
int[] freq = new int[26];
for (char c : str.toCharArray()) {
freq[c - 'a']++;
}
int maxVariance = 0;
for (int p = 0; p < 26; p++) {
for (int q = 0; q < 26; q++) {
// Ensure p and q are different characters and both have occurrences in the string
if (p == q || freq[p] == 0 || freq[q] == 0) continue;
char primary = (char)('a' + p);
char secondary = (char)('a' + q);
int countPrimary = 0;
int countSecondary = 0;
// Track secondary characters left in the remainder of the string
int remainingSecondary = freq[q];
for (char c : str.toCharArray()) {
if (c == primary) {
countPrimary++;
}
if (c == secondary) {
countSecondary++;
remainingSecondary--;
}
// Calculate variance where secondary is at least 1
if (countSecondary > 0)
maxVariance = Math.max(maxVariance, countPrimary - countSecondary);
// Reset counts if secondary can still form another segment
if (countPrimary < countSecondary && remainingSecondary > 0) {
countPrimary = 0;
countSecondary = 0;
}
}
}
}
return maxVariance;
}
}
The Java solution provided solves the problem of finding the "Substring with Largest Variance". The variance in this context is defined based on the frequency differences between two characters in substrings of a given string.
Approach Overview:
- First, the solution counts the frequency of each letter in the string using an array
freq
of size 26 (representing the alphabet). - The next step entails iterating over all possible pairs of characters
(p, q)
wherep != q
and both characters appear in the input string at least once. - For each character pair, a new sweep of the string is performed using two counters,
countPrimary
andcountSecondary
, which track the occurrences ofp
andq
respectively as the string is traversed. - A variable
remainingSecondary
counts the remaining occurrences of the secondary character as the string is parsed. - It then calculates the variance for segments where at least one occurrence of the secondary character exists, updating
maxVariance
if a higher variance is found using the formulacountPrimary - countSecondary
. - If a segment is found where the occurrences of
q
exceedp
, and if there are further occurrences ofq
ahead, both counters are reset to zero to start counting a new segment.
Steps Performed:
- Initialize an array
freq
to count occurrences of each character. - Use two nested loops to consider all pairs of characters as primary (
p
) and secondary (q
) respectively, ensuring different characters are selected. - Initialize counters and track the remaining secondary characters.
- Traverse through the string, updating the counters based on whether the character at the current position corresponds to
p
orq
. - Calculate and potentially update the
maxVariance
. - Reset both counters under specified conditions to handle subsequent segments of the string.
- Return
maxVariance
once all pairs have been analyzed.
Key Optimization:
- This solution efficiently manages the search space by limiting variance calculations to character pairs that both exist in the string, and by resetting and recalculating segment variance dynamically as new potential high variance segments are encountered.
No comments yet.