
Problem Statement
In the given problem, you are provided with an array of integers named nums. Your task is to identify two distinct indices i and j from this array such that the expression (nums[i]-1)*(nums[j]-1) attains its maximum possible value. The result you should return is this maximum value. This problem leverages basic array indexing and mathematical operations to find the optimum pair of numbers which when modified slightly (decremented by 1), their product is maximized.
Examples
Example 1
Input:
nums = [3,4,5,2]
Output:
12
Explanation:
If you choose the indices i=1 and j=2 (indexed from 0), you will get the maximum value, that is, (nums[1]-1)*(nums[2]-1) = (4-1)*(5-1) = 3*4 = 12.
Example 2
Input:
nums = [1,5,4,5]
Output:
16
Explanation:
Choosing the indices i=1 and j=3 (indexed from 0), you will get the maximum value of (5-1)*(5-1) = 16.
Example 3
Input:
nums = [3,7]
Output:
12
Constraints
2 <= nums.length <= 5001 <= nums[i] <= 10^3
Approach and Intuition
The primary goal here is to maximize the product of the values (nums[i]-1) and (nums[j]-1). This can theoretically be achieved by picking the two largest numbers in the array nums because once decremented by 1, their product will most likely be larger than that formed with smaller numbers. Here's a straightforward way to solve the problem:
Identify the two largest numbers in the array. Since sorting the array can simplify identification, we might start with that approach.
- Sort the array in descending order.
- Identify the two largest elements, which will be located at the beginning of the sorted array.
Calculate the product
(nums[0]-1)*(nums[1]-1).- This ensures that you are maximizing the product since
nums[0]andnums[1]are the largest elements in the sorted array.
- This ensures that you are maximizing the product since
This approach is efficient given the constraints and directly utilizes array indexing and sorting (where sorting dominates the computational complexity). The maximum possible size for the array is 500, making a sorting operation feasible, and since any sorting algorithm typically performs well within this range, the overall algorithm remains efficient.
Solutions
- C++
- Java
- Python
class Solution {
public:
int maximumProduct(vector<int>& numbers) {
int largest = 0;
int secondLargest = 0;
for (int value : numbers) {
if (value > largest) {
secondLargest = largest;
largest = value;
} else {
secondLargest = max(secondLargest, value);
}
}
return (largest - 1) * (secondLargest - 1);
}
};
This C++ solution focuses on finding the maximum product of two different elements in an array after each element has been decreased by one. The function maximumProduct receives a vector of integers and processes to find the two largest distinct values in the array.
- Start by initializing two integer variables,
largestandsecondLargest, both set to zero. - Iterate through the
numbersvector using a range-based for loop. - During each iteration, compare the current value with
largest. If it's greater:- Update
secondLargestto the value oflargest. - Set
largestto the current value.
- Update
- If the current value isn't larger than
largest, updatesecondLargestto be the maximum of the currentsecondLargestand the current value. - Finally, calculate and return the product
(largest - 1) * (secondLargest - 1).
This solution efficiently identifies the two largest unique values in a single traversal of the array, leading to an optimal time complexity of O(n), where n is the number of elements in the input vector.
class Solution {
public int maximumProduct(int[] values) {
int max1 = 0;
int max2 = 0;
for (int value : values) {
if (value > max1) {
max2 = max1;
max1 = value;
} else {
max2 = Math.max(max2, value);
}
}
return (max1 - 1) * (max2 - 1);
}
}
The code provided is a Java solution intended to find the maximum product of two elements minus one for each, from an input array. The function, maximumProduct, takes an integer array values as input. Here's a breakdown of how the solution is calculated:
- Initialize two integers,
max1andmax2, both set to 0. These variables keep track of the largest and second-largest values in the array. - Iterate through each element in the
valuesarray:- For each element, check if it is greater than
max1.- If true, the current
max1becomesmax2, andmax1is updated to the current value. - If false, update
max2to be the maximum between the currentmax2and the value.
- If true, the current
- For each element, check if it is greater than
- Finally, subtract one from both
max1andmax2, multiply them together, and return the result.
The procedure employs a single pass through the array, keeping the solution efficient with a time complexity of O(n), where n is the number of elements in the array. This method ensures that max1 always holds the highest value found, and max2 the second highest, which are required to calculate the desired product. This efficient method not only finds these values without sorting but also avoids using extra space, making it space-efficient with O(1) space complexity.
class Solution:
def calculateMaxProduct(self, numbers: List[int]) -> int:
max1 = 0
max2 = 0
for n in numbers:
if n > max1:
max2 = max1
max1 = n
elif n > max2:
max2 = n
return (max1 - 1) * (max2 - 1)
The provided code defines a Python function that determines the maximum product of two numbers from a list after decrementing each by one. The function, calculateMaxProduct, iterates through the list to identify the largest (max1) and second largest (max2) numbers. Using conditional logic during the iteration, it updates max1 and max2 appropriately. Once the maximum two numbers are identified, the function computes their product after subtracting one from each, and then returns the result.
Here's a concise overview on how the solution functions:
- Initialize two variables,
max1andmax2, to zero to store the maximum and the second maximum numbers from the list. - Loop through each number
nin the provided list:- Update
max1andmax2accordingly ifnis greater thanmax1ornis greater thanmax2.
- Update
- After completion of the loop, return the product
(max1 - 1) * (max2 - 1).
This approach efficiently determines the required maximum product by only scanning the list once, hence operates in O(n) time complexity, where n is the number of elements in the list.