
Problem Statement
In this problem, you are provided with a 2D integer array named events
, indexed from zero. Each inner array in events
denotes an event characterized by [startTimei, endTimei, valuei]
. Here, startTimei
and endTimei
represent the start and end times of the ith
event respectively, and valuei
is the reward received if you attend this event. You are tasked with choosing a maximum of two non-overlapping events such that the sum of their values is maximized. An event A
is considered non-overlapping with another event B
if the end time of A
is strictly less than the start time of B
, ensuring the condition that no two selected events have their times overlapping. You need to calculate and return the maximum sum of values you can achieve under these conditions.
Examples
Example 1
Input:
events = [[1,3,2],[4,5,2],[2,4,3]]
Output:
4
Explanation: Choose the green events, 0 and 1 for a sum of 2 + 2 = 4.
Example 2
Input:
events = [[1,3,2],[4,5,2],[1,5,5]]
Output:
5
Explanation:
Choose event 2 for a sum of 5.
Example 3
Input:
events = [[1,5,3],[1,5,1],[6,6,5]]
Output:
8
Explanation:
Choose events 0 and 2 for a sum of 3 + 5 = 8.
Constraints
2 <= events.length <= 105
events[i].length == 3
1 <= startTimei <= endTimei <= 109
1 <= valuei <= 106
Approach and Intuition
To tackle the problem of finding two non-overlapping events with the maximum sum of values, consider the following approach:
Sorting by End Times:
- Start by sorting the events based on their end times. Sorting helps in efficiently finding the next possible non-overlapping event.
Using Dynamic Programming for Assistance:
- Use a dynamic programming (DP) approach where
dp[i]
represents the maximum value achievable from the firsti
events. For every eventi
, consider:- Taking only this event, which will contribute its own value to the maximum.
- Pairing it with one of the earlier non-overlapping events to potentially increase the total value. Binary search on the
dp
array can help in efficiently finding the most recent non-overlapping event.
- Use a dynamic programming (DP) approach where
Binary Search for Non-overlapping Events:
- For each event, use binary search to find the last event that ends before the current event's start time. This helps in ensuring that the events considered are non-overlapping.
Optimization Checks:
- Once the
dp
array is filled up after considering all events, the answer to the problem will be the maximum value found in thedp
array. - Since adding an event to the selection can either increase the maximum sum or leave it unchanged, it is crucial to always check if the new event combination offers a better value than what was previously computed.
- Once the
Considerations Based on Constraints:
- With up to
105
events, sorting the events and utilizing a DP approach with efficient lookups (like binary search) ensures that the solution remains feasible within the given constraints. - Every step from sorting to filling up the DP array aims to work efficiently to handle the upper limits of the input sizes and values.
Solutions
- C++
- Java
- Python
class Solution {
public:
int maxTwoEvents(vector<vector<int>>& eventList) {
vector<array<int, 3>> intervals;
for (auto& event : eventList) {
intervals.push_back({event[0], 1, event[2]}); // Start of an event
intervals.push_back({event[1] + 1, 0, event[2]}); // End of an event
}
int maxResult = 0, currentMax = 0;
sort(intervals.begin(), intervals.end());
for (auto& interval : intervals) {
if (interval[1]) { // Start event; calculate potential max result
maxResult = max(maxResult, interval[2] + currentMax);
} else { // End event; update current max for ongoing calculations
currentMax = max(currentMax, interval[2]);
}
}
return maxResult;
}
};
The solution provided for determining the two best non-overlapping events from a list aims to compute the maximum combined value of any two non-overlapping events. Written in C++, the code leverages sorting and the sweep line algorithm for efficient calculation. Below is a breakdown of how the code approaches the problem:
- First, it initializes a vector of arrays to store both start and endpoint information of events. This setup also includes the value of the event.
- Each event undergoes splitting into two entries:
- The start time is marked by a '1' to signify starting a new event.
- The end time is recorded as 'event end time + 1', marked with a '0' to indicate the event's conclusion.
- This vector of interval entries is then sorted based on time. If multiple events share the same time, start times are prioritized as they are marked by '1', as per the sort routine in C++.
- The algorithm iterates through the sorted interval entries, using a variable
currentMax
to track the maximum value found up to the end of the latest event. - During the iteration:
- If a start of an event is encountered, it computes a potential maximum by adding the value of the current event to
currentMax
and checks if this combination exceeds any previously recorded combination stored inmaxResult
. - When an event end is encountered, it updates
currentMax
to ensure it holds the maximum ending event value so far.
- If a start of an event is encountered, it computes a potential maximum by adding the value of the current event to
- The result,
maxResult
, holds the maximum value of any two non-overlapping events, which is returned at the end.
Overall, the approach ensures efficient management of large data sets by minimizing unnecessary comparisons, and by logically breaking down event times into start and end points, it provides a straightforward method to determine overlaps and maximize value calculation.
class Solution {
public int maxSumOfTwoEvents(int[][] events) {
List<int[]> eventTimes = new ArrayList<>();
// Transform events into points of start time, end time, and their values
for (int[] event : events) {
eventTimes.add(new int[] { event[0], 1, event[2] }); // 1 indicates the start of an event
eventTimes.add(new int[] { event[1] + 1, 0, event[2] }); // 0 indicates the end of an event
}
// Sort the event times by time point, and start times before end times if equal
eventTimes.sort((x, y) ->
x[0] != y[0]
? Integer.compare(x[0], y[0])
: Integer.compare(x[1], y[1])
);
int maximumSum = 0, currentMaxValue = 0;
// Iterate through each time point
for (int[] time : eventTimes) {
if (time[1] == 1) { // Handling start of an event
maximumSum = Math.max(maximumSum, time[2] + currentMaxValue);
} else { // Handling end of an event
currentMaxValue = Math.max(currentMaxValue, time[2]);
}
}
return maximumSum;
}
}
In this Java solution, the objective is to compute the maximum sum of two non-overlapping events' values from a given list of events. Each event is represented by an array [start, end, value]
. The method named maxSumOfTwoEvents
is used to achieve this by following the steps below:
- Initialize an empty list of integer arrays named
eventTimes
to store transformed events. - Convert each event into two records: one marking the start and another marking the end. During this conversion:
- An event's start is represented as
[start_time, 1, value]
. - The end is adjusted to one unit after the actual
end_time
to clearly demarcate the scope of the event, represented as[end_time + 1, 0, value]
.
- An event's start is represented as
- Sort the
eventTimes
list based on the event's time. If multiple events have the same time, starts are processed before ends. - Initialize two integer variables,
maximumSum
to track the maximum sum of values of two non-overlapping events, andcurrentMaxValue
to capture the value of the most lucrative event encountered so far. - Iterate through each record in the sorted
eventTimes
list:- If the record marks the start of an event, calculate the potential maximum sum by adding the event's value to
currentMaxValue
. UpdatemaximumSum
if this calculated sum exceeds the currentmaximumSum
. - If the record marks the end of an event, update
currentMaxValue
to be the maximum of itself and the event's value, to ensure it reflects the highest value of any standalone event so far.
- If the record marks the start of an event, calculate the potential maximum sum by adding the event's value to
- Return the value of
maximumSum
, which now holds the maximum sum obtained from any two non-overlapping events.
This solution leverages sorting and linear iteration to efficiently determine the maximum possible value sum from any two non-overlapping events, ensuring that the overall time complexity remains manageable.
class Solution:
def maximumSumOfTwoEvents(self, event_list):
event_times = []
for event in event_list:
# Add start information
event_times.append([event[0], 1, event[2]])
# Add end information
event_times.append([event[1] + 1, 0, event[2]])
max_result, current_max = 0, 0
event_times.sort()
for item in event_times:
# When processing start of an event
if item[1]:
max_result = max(max_result, item[2] + current_max)
else:
current_max = max(current_max, item[2])
return max_result
The code provided is a Python solution designed for finding the maximum sum of values from two non-overlapping events in a given list. The approach utilized involves a series of steps to process and calculate the desired outcome:
Initialization of the Event List:
- Create an empty list
event_times
to store events' start, end, and value information distinctly.
- Create an empty list
Populating Time Stamps:
- Iterate through each event in the
event_list
to store both the start time (event[0]
) and just after the end time (event[1] + 1
) of an event along with its value (event[2]
). This helps in marking the beginning and the point just beyond the ending of an event.
- Iterate through each event in the
Sorting Event Times:
- Sort the
event_times
list to ensure that the events are processed in chronological order, which is necessary for the neat calculation of non-overlapping events.
- Sort the
Finding Maximum Sum:
- Iterate over the sorted
event_times
. Two distinct cases are considered for each time stamp:- Event Start (
item[1]
is True): Updatemax_result
by considering the maximum between the currentmax_result
or the sum of the event's value (item[2]
) andcurrent_max
. This condition helps in checking the value if the current event can be added without overlapping with any previous event. - Event End (
item[1]
is False): Updatecurrent_max
by comparing it with the event's value. This value represents the maximum sum of events processed up to this point without overlapping.
- Event Start (
- Iterate over the sorted
Return Result:
- At the end of the loop,
max_result
will store the maximum sum of two non-overlapping events, which is then returned.
- At the end of the loop,
This approach smartly uses sorting and linear traversal to maintain efficiency, while adequately handling non-overlapping conditions using logical separations of event starts and ends. The code is expected to be efficient with a complexity primarily dictated by the sort operation, i.e., O(n log n), where n is the number of events. The use of max operations within the loop does not significantly increase complexity but ensures the correct and optimal solution is derived by processing events in their orderly sequence. This method is both effective in tackling the problem of finding two best non-overlapping events and illustrating efficient use of data processing in Python.
No comments yet.